1. Working Principle
Plate Type Air Preheater (PAH)
- Uses a series of thin metal plates to transfer heat between flue gas and incoming air.
- The plates create separate channels for hot gases and cold air, ensuring efficient heat transfer.
- Provides high heat transfer efficiency with a compact design and minimal air leakage.
Tubular Air Preheater (TAH)
- Consists of a bundle of tubes where flue gas passes through the tubes, while air flows around them (or vice versa).
- Heat transfer occurs through the tube walls, preheating the incoming air.
- Typically used in large-scale power plants due to its durability and capacity.
2. Performance Comparison
Feature | Plate Type Air Preheater (PAH) | Tubular Air Preheater (TAH) |
---|
Heat Transfer Efficiency | Higher (large surface area) | Lower than PAH |
Size & Space Requirements | Compact, space-saving | Requires more space |
Air Leakage | Very low | Higher risk of leakage |
Maintenance | Easier (removable plates) | Difficult (tube cleaning required) |
Resistance to Fouling & Corrosion | Higher resistance | More prone to fouling |
Durability | Good, but plates may wear out over time | Highly durable, suitable for extreme conditions |
Cost | Generally lower | Higher initial investment |
3. Advantages of Each Type
✅ Advantages of Plate Type Air Preheater
✔ Compact Design: Requires less installation space, making it ideal for industries with space constraints.
✔ Higher Heat Transfer Efficiency: The plate structure allows for better thermal performance.
✔ Lower Air Leakage: Sealed plate edges minimize the risk of air leakage.
✔ Easier Maintenance: Plates can be removed and cleaned more conveniently than tubes.
✔ Better Corrosion Resistance: Suitable for industries dealing with corrosive gases.
✅ Advantages of Tubular Air Preheater
✔ Higher Durability: Tubes are robust and can withstand higher temperatures and pressures.
✔ Better for Large-Scale Operations: Ideal for power plants and high-capacity boilers.
✔ Handles Heavy Dust Load: Can operate in environments with significant soot and ash.
4. Applications of Each Type
Industry | Plate Type APH | Tubular APH |
---|
Power Plants | ✅ Used in smaller and medium boilers | ✅✅ Preferred for large-scale power generation |
Cement Industry | ✅ Suitable for preheating air in kilns | ✅ Commonly used in cement production |
Petrochemical Plants | ✅ Ideal for heat-sensitive processes | ✅ Used in large furnaces |
Steel Industry | ✅ Improves combustion efficiency in reheating furnaces | ✅ Used in blast furnaces and boilers |
Waste Heat Recovery | ✅ Excellent for recovering low-temperature heat | ✅ Suitable for high-temperature exhaust gases |
5. Which One Should You Choose?
✔ If space-saving, efficiency, and low air leakage are top priorities → Choose Plate Type Air Preheater.
✔ If high durability, large-scale operation, and heavy-duty performance are needed → Choose Tubular Air Preheater.
Both types have their strengths, and the right choice depends on your specific industry, operating conditions, and budget.
Conclusion
Plate type and tubular air preheaters each play a critical role in improving boiler efficiency, reducing fuel consumption, and lowering emissions. Understanding their differences allows industries to make informed decisions based on their operational needs.